Dnd 5e Crafting Rules Dmg

Aug 29, 2015 There is a persistent misunderstanding about buying and selling magic items in 5th Edition: that there’s no market for it. Certain people maintain that the Dungeon Master Guide specifically prohibits the existence of a magic item market, but this is, frankly, poor reading comprehension.

Questionable Arcana Crafting System
Item Crafting Rules	Artwork Crafting Rules
The Artisan's Tools
Alchemist's Supplies	Brewer's Supplies
Calligrapher's Supplies	Carpenter's Tools
Cartographer's Tools	Cobbler's Tools
Cook's Utensils	Glassblower's Tools
Jeweler's Tools	Leatherworker's Tools
Mason's Tools	Painter's Supplies
Poisoner's Kit	Potter's Tools
Smith's Tools	Tinker's Tools
Weaver's Tools	Woodcarver's Tools
Other Homebrew Rules
Critical Hit Charts	Wild Magic
More Martial Actions	D&D Drinking Game

IMPORTANT NOTICE: Although this crafting system leverages many existing mechanics published under the 5e SRD and OGL, the final product is completely home-brewed. The finer details of this system are still being revised, and those changes will slowly be introduced into this document. However, the system as a whole is totally functional and ready to be used in any campaign. Furthermore, the rules and concepts discussed are intended to work in-tandem with the expanded artisan's tools rules found in Xanathar's Guide to Everything. If nothing else I hope this document and its siblings can be used as a source of guidance and inspiration for whatever crafting system you decide to go with.

The Poisoner’s Kit At A Glance

RAW Cost: 50 GP
RAW Weight: 2 lbs
*Items: Mortar and Pestle, Mixing Flasks, Tweezers, Cloth, Stirring Rod
Crafting Restrictions: None
Mundane Item Crafting: Basic Poisons
Magic Item Crafting: Any Floral or Faunal Poison
Artwork Creation: N/A
QA Artwork Bonus: N/A
Structure Building: N/A
Adventuring Utility: Is able to more easily spot hidden poisons, and understands the effects of poisons

* These items are specific to the Questionable Arcana system. Other similar crafting systems may utilitize a different list of items.

Downtime Activity Proficiencies. When designing a class or backgrounds, you can use a downtime activity proficiency instead of a tool proficiency. If you have proficiency in Crafting, you can craft nonmagical items at a greater speed (PHB p. You still need to be proficient with the appropriate set of tools.
Mar 08, 2015 With about a month or so until the start of the my first 'proper' 5th edition campaign, I'd like to spend a moment hammering out the rules we're going to use to play the game. After more than two years of playtest packets and limited options, the whole breadth of the new PHB and DMG are.
5th Edition I wanted to encourage my players to do a bit of crafting. Since the rules are kind of spread out between the PHB and DMG, I wrote a couple pages out on Homebrewery to consolidate everything with the house rules we'd be using.

I’ve finally seen my modifications to the 5e crafting system in action, and I must say I’ve been very happy with the results. However, in the course of explaining its mechanics to my players, I noticed some areas that still needed a little fine-tuning. In an attempt to flesh out the aforementioned crafting system, I’m going to do a series of articles featuring specifics from each kit. The first kit in the Questionable Arcana Crafting Series is going to be the Poisoner’s Kit.

Before we begin, it’s worth noting that the primary purpose of this article isn’t to layer a bunch of new mechanics on top of what we already have. Don’t get me wrong; there will certainly be additional mechanics and clarifications, but the idea is to go through a couple of crafting “case studies”, helping other DMs apply the new crafting system manage some of the issues or loopholes you could encounter.

If nothing else, think of this series as something to reference when you need inspiration for uses of the system.

First, A Quick Overview of the Rules As Written (RaW)

The existing rules for extracting and using poisons harvested from creatures are pretty solid. You kill the creature and attempt a DC 20 Nature Check to harvest the poison, with a successful check yielding either a one-use poison you can apply to a blade for one minute or three pieces of ammunition. A failed check makes it impossible to harvest the poison, and a failure by 5 or more subjects the player to the poison. The effect of the poison is based on the creature’s description, matching the effect applied after the target makes its savings throw.

If I were only allowing poisons harvested from creatures, this would be sufficient. It is simple, effective, and doesn’t leave too much room for abuse (more on that later). However, the Rogue in my 5e campaign made it his personal goal to learn how to craft Floral Poisons. Being the generous DM that I am, I decided to do what I do best: run through dozens of hypothetical situations with Truck until we produced some concrete rules.

The Problem with Floral Poisons

5th edition doesn’t detail many rules regarding plants, much less how to turn those plants into poisons. It doesn’t even attempt to address the implications of a player who decides to try and create his own Brownroot farm in hopes of mass producing a furious bowel poison.

The gold-based crafting system works beautifully when all components are being purchased on the market. For example, explaining the crafting process of a garden-variety poison in the Adventuring Gear section of The Player’s Handbook is easy enough. Essentially, you’re trying to create a stable poison out of various household ingredients, which requires some pricey objects if you’re buying in a normal market.

But what happens when a player creates the aforementioned Brownroot farm, enabling him or her to procure a massive glut of the poison’s active ingredient? With the cost factor largely removed, things could quickly spiral out of control, ending with an entire party permanently toting poisoned short swords with overpowered effects!

The Solution to Floral Poisons

Rather than creating arbitrary limits on how much of a given herb you can harvest, I realized the cost mechanic could still be applied in this situation. As far as I know, there are no magical poisons in The Dungeon Masters Guide, so any plant-harvested poison can be considered a mundane item. Mundane items in both my home-brewed system and RaW have a base gold cost of 50% of the value of the item being created.

In this case, the best solution is to simply alter where the costs lie in the poison crafting process. The majority of plants the DM introduces as “craftable” reagents can’t just be mashed up and applied to a weapon. Creating a stable poison requires a variety of chemicals and a great deal of steeping time to extract the poisonous effects from the plants. So even with a Brownroot stockpile, the majority of the costs remain tied up in other ingredients. With this modification, you’re now able to apply a gold-based crafting process to plant-based poison formulas.

Your players may protest and point to real life examples of plants which can be immediately applied to a weapon. You can fold your arms and say they don’t exist in your world, but there’s no reason these simpler floral poisons can’t coexist with the more complex. The party may occasionally find these “instant” poisons in the wild, but I recommend restricting the environments they grown in to avoid abuse. For example, a hypothetical Firevein plant capable of dealing 1d6 fire + 1d6 poison damage on injury can only be found on the slopes of an active volcano.

Faunal Poisons

As stated above, the rules as written for extracting poisons from creatures are already fairly effective. A DC 20 Nature check, modified by your Poisoner’s Kit proficiency, is very reasonable and also scales into later levels. Furthermore the rules already require that the creature either be dead or incapacitated, and the process itself takes 1d6 minutes. This greatly limits the players ability to harvest poisons from a live target, however there are a couple of loopholes the DM should be aware of.

The first and most obvious source of abuse is harvesting poison from a player-controlled pet or companion. Although most creatures eligible for those roles have fairly weak poisons, some notable exceptions could cause major power creep late into the campaign.

Let’s say you allow a beast conclave ranger to choose a giant poisonous snake as a familiar. Because the snake generally follows your orders without question, a clever player might try to milk the snake regularly to amass a poison stockpile. Rather than disallowing this behavior, I’d recommend some simple restrictions.

First and foremost, I’d limit the milking rate to at most once per long rest. Secondly, I’d require more than one milking to get enough venom for a useful poison. If harvesting a full venom sac from a dead creature typically yields one dose, a milked creature would likely have a lower yield. Lastly, a “milked” creature loses the ability to apply its poison in combat until it has taken a long rest. This is typically only an issue for home-brewed classes, such as the 5e Beastmaster, but these rules will help avoid power creep.

The last potential pet-related loophole I want to cover is a player who decides to go off the deep end and make a zoo to house all the poisonous creatures they find. This could hypothetically grow into a never-ending source of free poison, but it can once again be easily managed by the crafting cost formula.

Any large-scale creature milking operation would require staff to maintain the buildings and feed/milk the creatures. You’d likely also need a consistent supply of antivenom to prevent loss of life in the event of a staff member getting bitten. You can itemize this, but I’d recommend assigning a value to the poison being harvested and utilize crafting formulae with the values shifted towards the maintenance of the facility. For example: 4 staff members proficient in the Poisoner’s Kit harvesting poisonous snakes would milk 4d4*5+20 worth of venom per day from the snakes. If you assigned a value of 200 GP to the poison, it would take, on average, just under 3 days for the team to produce a unit of venom.

In the event that a character attempts to sell any poison on the market, I would limit the volume they are able to sell. I recommend using the RAW rules for selling a magic items on page 130 of The Dungeon Master’s Guide.

Poisons Derived from Magically Created Material

There are a couple of spells in the game that could potentially be used to create poisonous materials. The biggest offender would definitely be the Creation spell which allows for the creation of non-living vegetable matter for up to a day. The relatively short duration should disallow crafted poisons such as the hypothetical brownroot poison discussed above.

However, a shrewd player might try to create a large amount of instantly usable poison such as the firevein example from above. In this case I would actually recommend that you allow this behavior, but with one important caveat, you need to strictly enforce the material requirement of the Creation spell. Creation requires a tiny piece of matter of the same type of the item you plan to create. This means that the caster needs to have some of the poisonous material in their possession to be able to create it. Granting the entire party poisonous weapons is actually an appropriately powerful effect for a 5th level spell, and requiring the party to have previously encountered the poison allows the DM to manage the power level of the poisons the party can create.

The last loophole I want to cover is if a magically summoned poisonous creature such as a familiar, conjured animal, or wild-shaped druid attempts to create a poison. This situation is easily managed by using the same poison milking rules listed above for pets. This essentially creates a trade-off of requiring the use of a spells/wild-shape and additional spells to incapacitate the creature for some temporarily usable poisons. The poisons are temporary because any poisons harvested from the magically created creatures only stay in the world as long as the magic is in effect. Once the magical effect ends all unused poisons disappear. However, it is worth noting that any damage dealt from the poison stays in effect, however any statuses linked to a long-term poisoning such as the poisoned effect should quickly wear off once the poison disappears.

Crafting With The Poisoner’s Kit

On the crafting front, the Poisoner’s Kit has a short but solid list of options.

Questionable Arcana Item Crafting Rules At A Glance

Overview: The Questionable Arcana Crafting System is a homebrew set of rules that builds on the RAW crafting system. The goal of the system is to increase the rate that items are crafted while introducing an element of variability(aka dice rolling).

Crafting Requirements

A Lead Artisan - An artisan with the appropriate tool who can lead the crafting process.
Crafting Materials - Materials to craft with. The items should be valued at 50% market value for mundane items and 100% market value for magical items.
Means of Production - Any special equipment or location requirements such as a forge for blacksmiths.
Instructions - Memorized instructions for mundane items or a written blueprint for magical items.
Labor - Time and energy measured in 8 hour increments and proficiency dice rolls!

Crafting Capabilities Definitions

LEAD - You can serve as the lead artisan when creating this item.
ASSIST - You can work under a lead artisan to create this item.
OPTIONAL - You could potentially create a non-RAW version of this item at the DM's discretion.
N/A - You cannot use this toolkit to contribute to the creation of this item.
SPECIAL - Special cases defined on a case by case basis.

Crafting GP Progression Formula

[PROGRESS IN GP] = 5 + (Proficiency_Dice_Roll * 5)

Important Disclaimer: The Questionable Arcana Crafting Rules and lists are not official material. The concepts and ideas provided by this write-up are simply suggestions. I happen to think they are good suggestions, but ultimately your table's DM has the final say when it comes to any and all crafting rulings.

Adventuring Gear Crafting List
Item	Cost	Weight	Crafting Capability
Acid (vial)	25 GP	1 lb.	LEAD
Alchemist’s Fire (flask)	50 GP	1 lb.	LEAD
Antitoxin (vial)	50 GP	—	LEAD
Poison, Basic (vial)	100 GP	—	LEAD
Ale, Gallon	2 SP	—	ASSIST
Ale, Mug	4 CP	—	ASSIST
Wine, Common(Pitcher)	2 SP	—	ASSIST
Wine, Fine(Bottle)	10 GP	—	ASSIST

When it comes to magic items there are no RAW options the Poisoner’s Kit can create. However, this lack of magical options is offset by the fact that you can create the plethora of harvest poisons mentioned earlier in this write-up.

Mixing Poisons

Eventually a party member will get the brilliant idea of mixing all of the poisons they have in a jug and using it as a bottomless well of murder ink for their sword. To handle this situation, just dilute and combine the effects proportionally. If you take a poison that causes paralysis for 6 rounds and mix with with a poison that deals 2d6 damage hit, the product would be two units of poison that paralyze for 3 rounds, dealing 1d6 damage on hit.

Optional Rule: The process of mixing poisons causes the individual poisons to lose some of their potency. With this rule in effect, the example mixture above would only paralyze for 2 rounds and deal 1d4 damage on hit.

Applied Toxicology

Beyond just creating poisons, proficiency in the poisoner’s kit gives the player a bonus when dealing with poisons during their adventures. It stands to reason that any player who is familiar with the properties of poisons would be able to more easily identify when poisons are being used against them.

For example should a party member start to become sluggish after being struck by a dart trap, the player with poisoner’s kit proficiency should be able to add their poisoner’s kit proficiency bonus to any check required to identify the type of poison they are under. This bonus should be layered on top of any existing proficiency they already have as well. For example if a level 5 player with 14 intelligence, proficiency in investigation, and the poisoner’s kit is investigating a cup of wine to check if it is poisoned, they should add +8(+2 Ability Score Modifier, +3 Investigation, +3 Poisoner’s Kit) to their investigation check against the poisoned cup.

Final Thoughts

These rules and standards hopefully clear up a lot of the gray areas around poison crafting. We now have some concrete rules around creating plant-based poisons, and have addressed some of the major loopholes surrounding creature-based poisons. Much like the base crafting system, I did my best to avoid creating new reagent and rules tables. However, if your party has spent a bit too much time playing Stardew Valley and decides to open up the world’s sketchiest family farm, this system can be expanded to accommodate their needs.

Back to The Top
D&D Homebrew - Latest Arcana	Campaign Journal - Latest Chapter
All Arcana

The Latest G^G Articles

Let’s Play Druidstone – Episode 01: Dawnstone Meadow
May 19, 2019
The First Level of Druidstone features rangers, druids, priests and cancer. I guess oncology is one way to really raise the stakes right away! […]
Satisfactory Early Access – Episode 11: Caterium, Supercomputers, and Geothermal Power
May 16, 2019
After some offline exploration, I found a new type of ore called Caterium that gives us access to all manner of advanced electronics!
[…]
The Tanius Campaign Journal – Chapter 29: Stone Cold Redemption
May 8, 2019
The Syndicate's second trip into the dig site ends with a glorious battle, and an unusual resolution.
[…]
Tavern Tycoon – Episode 10: Dragon’s Hangover
May 2, 2019
This is it! The last stage of Tavern Tycoon. Let's see if we can apply everything we have learned that far and complete our final challenge.
[…]
[G^G] May 2019 Update – I’m Getting Married!
April 30, 2019
After 14 months of planning Meesh and I are finally getting married! While all that is going on, check out a look back on what we've done, and what is to come.
[…]
Satisfactory Early Access – Episode 10: The Jetpack, Manufacturing, and The Edge of The World
April 28, 2019
Today we demonstrate proper splitting and merging, computer and heavy modular frame manufacturing, and why you shouldn't jump off the edge of the world...
[…]

Questionable Arcana Crafting System
Item Crafting Rules	Artwork Crafting Rules
The Artisan's Tools
Alchemist's Supplies	Brewer's Supplies
Calligrapher's Supplies	Carpenter's Tools
Cartographer's Tools	Cobbler's Tools
Cook's Utensils	Glassblower's Tools
Jeweler's Tools	Leatherworker's Tools
Mason's Tools	Painter's Supplies
Poisoner's Kit	Potter's Tools
Smith's Tools	Tinker's Tools
Weaver's Tools	Woodcarver's Tools
Other Homebrew Rules
Critical Hit Charts	Wild Magic
More Martial Actions	D&D Drinking Game

Updates – 2017/05/30

The crafting location contribution bonus now counts as progress towards building an artisan’s tool proficiency and expertise.
Gaining expertise now requires 15,000 GP(up from 10,000 GP) worth of crafting contributions.
Defined who is able to imbue magical items(magic users or non-magic users who have satisfied special conditions defined by the DM)

There are a lot of things that players and DMs disagree on when it comes to 5th edition. Should natural 1s and 20s matter on ability checks? Should we use critical hit tables in our campaign? Does Eldritch Blast need to be removed from the game?

In fact, we disagree on so many things, it seems miraculous we can finish a fight in a four-hour session. Still, there’s one thing I think nearly all participants in a 5th edition D&D campaign can agree on: the base crafting rules provided by Wizards of The Coast need some help.

Now, Now, Let’s Keep Things Positive

The reason I put this system in place was to add a bit more structure and depth to the existing rules. I wanted a system that was consistent and flexible, but still true to 5th edition’s theme of keeping things simple.

As you read on, you may notice my system has some similarities to the standard crafting system. Despite the shortcomings of the existing system, I did my best to leverage the parts that did work. The end result allows players to create items faster, involves more dice rolling, gives players access to tool proficiencies, and allows them to boost these proficiencies over time.

One Last Thing

Before we dig into the nitty-gritty, I think it’s important to explain what this crafting system is not.

This system will NOT feature a matrix of tables containing crafting materials and spell effects based on item type. This system does its best to utilize RAW items and mechanics wherever possible. The intent is to improve on the existing rules without adding excessive bookkeeping.

With that out of the way, let’s break this down.

System Overview

At a basic level, crafting any item using our system has 5 requirements:

A Lead Artisan – one artisan who is proficient with the crafting tool required to craft the item and meets the minimum level requirements to craft the item. This section has some minor differences from the original rules.
Crafting Materials – The materials the instructions call for, mundane or otherwise. Mundane items should cost roughly 50% of the item’s market value, and magic items should cost 100%. This section is basically the same as the original rules, but I added some clarification on what the artisans are spending their money on during the crafting process for magical items.
Means of Production – Some crafting processes only require the crafting kit, but others may require special equipment, like a forge. Magical items can also require special conditions for the item to be made. This section is similar to the original rules, but I added some structure to the mechanics around crafting locations.
Instructions – Either memorized instructions or a written blueprint/recipe detailing the materials and the process. This section is nearly identical to the original rules.
Labor – Once all four of the previous conditions are satisfied, the crafting process can begin. The artisans work in 8 hour increments to contribute progress measured in GP. This section is heavily modified from the original rules.

Now, each requirement in more detail.

Requirement 1: The Lead Artisan

Crafting an item requires one artisan with proficiency in the crafting tool associated with the item. The artisan also needs to meet the minimum level requirement to craft the item. This person serves as the Lead Artisan on the project, contributing to the item’s construction and enabling apprentice artisans to contribute. As long as you have a Lead Artisan, members of the party who are not proficient in the tool required, or do not meet the minimum player level, are still able to contribute to the crafting process.

The only requirement to craft mundane items (those in Chapter 5 of The Player’s Handbook) is tool proficiency. Mundane items have no level restriction.

Magic items, on the other hand, require the Lead Artisan to meet a level requirement based on the rarity of the item being created. A table detailing this information can be found in the Dungeon Master’s Guide on page 129, but for your convenience I’ve included it here:

Item Rarity	Minimum Player Level
Common	3rd
Uncommon	3rd
Rare	6th
Very Rare	11th
Legendary	17th

Requirement 2: Crafting Materials

For mundane items, the crafting materials can be acquired anywhere adventuring gear can be purchased. The standard price of materials is 50% of the value of the final item. Discounts to material costs can be obtained by making deals with local guilds and suppliers. These discounts are assessed at the DM’s discretion.

Magical effects are added to items by using gemstones to imbue the items with magical essence. The gemstones required and method of imbuing are determined by the crafting recipe. The spells required in the imbuing process are also determined by the crafting instructions, all of which are ultimately designed by the DM.

On top of gemstones, there may be other special materials required. For example: an Adamantium Breastplate may require the player to acquire a set amount of adamantium. The overall cost and/or difficultly of acquiring said items is also determined by the DM.

Any materials required beyond the gemstones must be crafted at full cost. The final combined cost of a magical item is set by the DM, but should be derived from the item’s rarity.

The item rarity table can be found in the Dungeon Master’s Guide on page 129, but I’ve included it here as well:

Item Rarity	Minimum Creation Cost
Common	100 GP
Uncommon	500 GP
Rare	5,000 GP
Very Rare	50,000 GP
Legendary	500,000 GP

Detailed examples of the cost structure can be found in Requirement 4: Instructions.

Requirement 3: Means of Production

At a basic level, the means of production for any crafting process are the crafting tools (with or without proficiency) and a crafting location. Most crafting projects do not require a location, but all can benefit from the use of a crafting location. Crafting locations confer a standard bonus detailed by the table below, but at the DM’s discretion players can find, construct, or utilize inferior/superior crafting locations capable of granting a greater bonus.

Artisan’s Tools	Crafting Requirements	Ideal Crafting Location	Ideal Location Bonus
Alchemist’s Supplies	Access to fire	Lab	+10 GP
Brewer’s Supplies	Access to a brewery	Brewery	+10 GP
Calligrapher’s supplies	None	Studio	+10 GP
Carpenter’s Tools	Access to a workshop	Workshop	+10 GP
Cartographer’s Tools	None	Studio	+10 GP
Cobbler’s Tools	None	Workshop	+10 GP
Cook’s Utensils	Access to fire	Kitchen	+10 GP
Glassblower’s Tools	Access to fire	Studio	+10 GP
Jeweler’s Tools	None	Studio	+10 GP
Leatherworker’s Tools	None	Workshop	+10 GP
Mason’s Tools	Access to workshop	Workshop	+10 GP
Painter’s Supplies	None	Studio	+10 GP
Poisoner’s Kit	None	Lab	+10 GP
Potter’s Tools	Access to fire	Studio	+10 GP
Smith’s Tools	Access to forge	Forge	+10 GP
Tinker’s Tools	Access to Workshop	Workshop	+10 GP
Weaver’s Tools	None	Studio	+10 GP
Woodcarver’s Tools	None	Workshop	+10 GP

The process of imbuing an item with magical properties requires a connection to the magical weave. All spellcasters by default are able to interface with the weave and as a result can assist with imbuing an item. At the DM’s discretion non-casters such as barbarians can eventually learn to imbue magical items, but this is typically obtained through either extensive training, or through special circumstances such as divine intervention.

Requirement 4: Instructions

For mundane items, the instructions requirement is met simply by having a Lead Artisan proficient in the tool required to construct the item.

For magical items, the instructions typically come in the form of a written recipe. Recipes can be given out as quest rewards or found in the course of exploration. An NPC with knowledge of the item could also serve as a Lead Artisan, enabling you to craft the item.

Dnd 5e Crafting Rules Dmg 2017

EXAMPLE: Crafting a Doss Lute

Recipe: Doss Lute
Item Rarity: Uncommon
Total Material Cost: 1035 GP
Mundane Item To Be Crafted: Lute
Gemstones/Special Materials Required: 3x Coral, 7x Pearl
Spells Required: Fly, Invisibility, Levitate, Protection From Evil and Good, Animal friendship, Protection from Energy, Protection from Poison

Crafting Instructions: A magic user must imbue each of the pearls with the 7 spells required by the recipe. The pearls are then set underneath each of the 7 bars in the lute. The 3 coral must then be imbued with magical force (no specific spell required). The coral is then set into the base of the chamber.

This example is for demonstration only; ultimately it is up to the DM to determine how to fulfill this requirement. This same item in a different campaign could have totally different crafting requirements.

Requirement 5: Labor

One crafting session lasts 8 hours. At the end of 8 hours, the progress in GP of the item(s) being crafted advances by each artisan’s individual crafting progression plus the location bonus.

The base crafting rate for mundane items is 5 GP. The base crafting rate for imbuing magical items is 25 GP.

Artisans proficient in the tools being used roll a proficiency die at the end of a crafting session and multiply the result by 5 to determine how much extra GP progress is added. The proficiency dice table used can be found on page 263 of the Dungeons Master Guide, and here:

Character Level	Proficiency Die
1st – 4th	1d4
5th – 8th	1d6
9th – 12th	1d8
13th – 16th	1d10
17th – 20th	1d12

When crafting magical items, magic users participating in the imbuing process do not need to have proficiency in the artisan’s tools. However, if they are proficient in the tools, they may add their proficiency roll multiplied by 5 to the imbuing process at the end of an 8 hour session.

An apprentice participating in the crafting process who is not proficient in the tools required can eventually gain proficiency. Once an apprentice has contributed 500 GP worth of crafting contributions using a single set of artisan’s tools, they gain proficiency in those tools. An apprentice only gains proficiency progress when assisting in the crafting of mundane items. Crafting progress gained while creating artwork is also counted, however a different set of crafting rules are used in the artwork creation process. Contributions provided by imbuing a magical item do not count towards the initial process of gaining tool proficiency.

Over time, as an artisan hones their skills, they can eventually become an expert at their craft. Once the artisan has contributed 15,000 GP worth of progress using a single set of tools, they’ve achieved expertise in those tools. Expertise allows the artisan to roll an additional proficiency die when using said tools. All crafting progress utilizing a tool the artisan is proficient with, including creating artwork and imbuing magical items, counts towards the 15,000 GP total.

Crafting Formula Example: 4 Players Crafting Plate Mail

If four artisans were building a plate mail and there was one expert artisan(PC level 4), one proficient artisan(PC level 3), and two apprentices(PC Level 3); the daily GP progress formula would be as follows:

Dmg Dnd 5e Pdf

[5 + 2d4 * 5](Expert Artisan) + [5+1d4 * 5](Proficient Artisan) + 5(Apprentice Artisan) + 5(Apprentice Artisan) +10(Location Bonus) = 20 + 3d4 * 5(37.5 Average) + 10 = ~67.5 GP/day

Finally there is currently no defined limitation on how many artisans can contribute to a single project. It is at the DM’s discretion to decide if the number of artisans on a project is reasonable.

In Conclusion

I believe the above system does a good job of enriching the RAW crafting system. The bookkeeping and table referencing is kept to a minimum, and it’s simple enough that any DM can pick it up and immediately apply it to their campaign.

As I see the system in practice in my own campaign, I will make minor updates to the rules. However, the concepts used in the rules above should remain mostly unchanged, and I encourage DMs to tweak the system to fit their needs.

Dnd 5e Crafting Rules Dmg Download

Back to The Top
D&D Homebrew - Latest Arcana	Campaign Journal - Latest Chapter
All Arcana

Dnd 5e Rules Book

The Latest G^G Articles

Let’s Play Druidstone – Episode 01: Dawnstone Meadow
May 19, 2019
The First Level of Druidstone features rangers, druids, priests and cancer. I guess oncology is one way to really raise the stakes right away! […]
Satisfactory Early Access – Episode 11: Caterium, Supercomputers, and Geothermal Power
May 16, 2019
After some offline exploration, I found a new type of ore called Caterium that gives us access to all manner of advanced electronics!
[…]
The Tanius Campaign Journal – Chapter 29: Stone Cold Redemption
May 8, 2019
The Syndicate's second trip into the dig site ends with a glorious battle, and an unusual resolution.
[…]
Tavern Tycoon – Episode 10: Dragon’s Hangover
May 2, 2019
This is it! The last stage of Tavern Tycoon. Let's see if we can apply everything we have learned that far and complete our final challenge.
[…]
[G^G] May 2019 Update – I’m Getting Married!
April 30, 2019
After 14 months of planning Meesh and I are finally getting married! While all that is going on, check out a look back on what we've done, and what is to come.
[…]
Satisfactory Early Access – Episode 10: The Jetpack, Manufacturing, and The Edge of The World
April 28, 2019
Today we demonstrate proper splitting and merging, computer and heavy modular frame manufacturing, and why you shouldn't jump off the edge of the world...
[…]